Features August 2010 Issue

Over-Vaccination - Dog Owners Beware

Educate yourself on canine vaccination practices.

You check your mailbox and there it is: a reminder postcard from your dog’s veterinarian. If you’re like many of us dog owners, you groan and toss the card aside.

If you’ve not yet found an enlightened, up-to-date veterinarian, the postcard is likely to say, “It’s time for your dog’s annual vaccinations! Call us today for an appointment!”

We hope, however, that you’ve done your homework and found a veterinary practice whose postcards say something more like, “It’s time for your dog’s wellness examination! Call us today for an appointment!”

Educate yourself on canine vaccination practices using reputable sources so that you can have an intelligent conversation with your veterinarian on the pros and cons of vaccination for your dog; a good place to start are the AAHA Guidelines.

What’s the difference? In 2003, the American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA) revised its vaccination guidelines, recommending that vets vaccinate adult dogs only every three years – not annually. Many enlightened veterinarians changed their canine healthcare protocols to reflect the guidelines, and now suggest annual wellness examinations with vaccinations only every three years.

In WDJ’s opinion (and that of the experts we consult), annual vaccination for most canine diseases is unnecessary and potentially harmful. Dog owners should avoid employing those old-fashioned veterinarians who recommend annual vaccines. Owners should also avoid those veterinary service providers who provide inexpensive vaccines and other routine care without the benefit of a relationship with you and your dog beyond a brief transaction in a parking lot or pet supply store. While the financial cost of vaccine clinics may be appealing, the fact is, your dog’s health may pay the price of unnecessary or inappropriate vaccines.

Be prepared
That said, don’t think for a minute that you need to take your dog to the vet only every three years. It’s imperative that you take your canine companions in for yearly checkups. Rather than throw that postcard in the trash, pick up the phone and call for an appointment. Yearly wellness examinations help our veterinarian develop a good baseline on our dog’s health, be better able to take notice of subtle changes in his health over time, and develop a relationship with our dog and us.

While these annual trips to the vet might now be called “wellness checks” rather than “vaccine visits,” the odds are good that the topic of vaccines will come up. And despite our good intentions, many of us head in with our dog for his annual exam and feel blindsided as the vet suggests an array of vaccines for our dogs. Often, we nod in agreement, get that “deer in the headlights” look and agree with her recommendations (she is the expert after all), then go home with regrets.

Remember the Scout motto and “Be prepared” as you get ready for your dog’s next veterinary appointment. Being prepared means more than remembering to take your dog’s leash, collar with ID, treats, and showing up on time, on the right day, with the right dog. How to best prepare for your dog’s annual veterinary visit and be ready for a discussion on the most appropriate vaccine strategy for him?

  • Bring veterinary records and/or a list with you of your dog’s vaccination history; do not assume the veterinary clinic will have all the most recent information, especially if you’ve changed clinics. Other test dates and results to bring include most recent heartworm test, antibody titer test results, and blood and/or urinalysis test results. Ideally, you’ll collect all the data ahead of time and enter into a table so that you have a timeline of the pet’s life.

My dogs’ veterinarian, Susan Wynn, DVM, recommends creating a table with vaccines/yearly wellness test along the vertical axis, with dates along the top. If visiting a new clinic, chances are they’ll want proof that your summary is accurate, so request copies of any previous vet records for your dog’s new file.

  • Have a clear idea in your mind whether you want/need your dog to receive any vaccinations (and for which diseases), an antibody titer test, or none of the above. If you are unsure, cultivate a good understanding of the vaccines available (see page 7 for a list of past WDJ articles on the topic). And ask your veterinarian if any particular vaccines are warranted due to conditions in the area in which you live.
  • Educate yourself using reputable sources so that you can have an intelligent conversation with your veterinarian on the pros and cons of vaccination for your dog; a good place to start are the AAHA Guidelines. Writings and research by Ronald Schultz, PhD, DACVIM, and Jean Dodds, DVM, are also excellent references.
  • Know the status of your dog’s health, and whether he has any health or behavioral issues that your veterinarian should be aware of.
  • Bring a list of your dog’s current medications and supplements, including dose, strength, and frequency.
  • Have an idea of what the visit will cost, including any tests, to avoid sticker shock or making hasty (bad) decisions based solely on price. Call ahead.
  • Be prepared to take your dog and go home if you are uncomfortable with your veterinarian’s recommendations. There’s no need to get nasty or defensive. We suggest something along the lines of, “I’m not sure I’m comfortable with those recommendations. I’d like to go home and think about them.”

If you are going to see a veterinarian who is new to you and your dog, consider making an appointment with the veterinarian, without your dog, to discuss her philosophy toward vaccinations and antibody titer tests.

Even a little education goes a long way
Michelle Kitzrow, of Sugar Hill, Georgia, had a change in thinking regarding vaccine protocols after hearing immunology expert Dr. Schultz speak on the topic (see “Vaccinations 101,” WDJ August 2008). Armed with a new understanding of vaccine protocols, Kitzrow took her then-four-year-old Bouvier, Casey, in to see her longtime veterinarian for Casey’s annual exam.

She admits that it “wasn’t very easy” to convince her veterinarian that, in lieu of vaccinations, Casey should receive an antibody titer test to determine whether she had what vaccination experts regard as a “protective level” of circulating antibodies from past vaccinations. But in the end, Kitzrow’s veterinarian relented, and agreed to take and send a blood sample off to a lab for the titer test.

Kitzrow believes that it was the relationship she already had established with Casey’s veterinarian, along with a new and accurate understanding of vaccines, that helped her veterinarian to support her decision. “He knows that I bring in my dogs regularly for veterinary care, and he trusts me to do the right thing. He also appreciated that I had taken the time to educate myself about vaccine protocols and titers.”

An acquaintance of mine, Diane (name changed at her request), had a bit harder time at the annual exam convincing her veterinarian to check her dog’s antibody titers instead of reflexively vaccinating – despite an 18-year relationship with her dogs’ veterinary clinic and the fact that she takes in her dogs twice a year for checkups. Diane’s 16-month-old Bouvier had received a puppy vaccine series, with the final boosters given after she was 16 weeks of age. The series included distemper, hepatitis (adenovirus), parvovirus, parainfluenza (shorthand for this combination of four vaccinations is DHPP), rabies, Leptospirosis, and Bordetella.

"Yeah, hmm, I don't think so." The fact that you receive a postcard from your veterinarian suggesting that your dog is "due" for certain vaccines does NOT mean your dog must have those vaccines!

“At my dog’s most recent vet checkup, I requested that only the rabies vaccine be given. I asked that titers be checked for distemper and parvovirus, and I requested a SNAP® 4Dx® test, which checks for heartworm disease, as well as the most prevalent tick-borne diseases: ehrlichiosis, Lyme disease, and anaplasmosis. 

“I declined the combo, ‘all-in-one’ vaccine for distemper, hepatitis, parvovirus, and parainfluenza, as well as the Leptospirosis and Bordetella vaccines. I did not want all of those vaccines given at the same time and hoped that the titer results would show adequate immunity. I was adamant that my dog receive only the rabies vaccine at that time. The vet marked ‘refused’ on my dog’s chart next to the other vaccines she wanted my dog to receive that day.”

Diane understands that Lepto and Bordetella need to be given at least yearly to be effective, but has made the decision not to re-vaccinate her dog for those diseases at this time and understands the risk. Dr. Wynn notes that while we as clients might consider a notation of “refused” on our dog’s chart to be judgmental on the veterinarian’s part, the reason that the vet must note in the file that the client declined vaccination is to limit liability in case the animal is infected with that disease and subsequently blames the vet. (Dr. Wynn assures me that this has happened.)

“In this particular situation, it turns out that my decision to decline all of the ‘recommended’ vaccines, except for the rabies booster, was a good choice as the SNAP 4Dx (checked in-house afterward) indicated that my dog has Lyme disease. A follow-up Lyme Quantitative C6 Antibody Test confirmed an active Lyme disease infection, which means that her immune system was already compromised at the time of the exam. The distemper and parvo vaccine titers showed adequate immunologic response, indicating that my dog was still protected against these diseases, most likely from her previous round of vaccinations.”

In fact, vaccinating a dog who has an active Lyme infection might have been harmful. “It is never wise to vaccinate a dog whose immune system is preoccupied with something else,” asserts internal medicine specialist Nancy Kay, DVM, DACVIM, author of Speaking for Spot: Be the Advocate Your Dog Needs to Live a Happy, Healthy, Longer Life. “The vaccine might ‘distract’ the immune system from the more important task at hand. Also, in theory and for the same reason, the vaccine might not be as likely to create protective immunity.”

Similar to Kitzrow, Diane finds that “Although my dogs’ veterinarian gets exasperated by the decisions I make that are counter to her recommendations, she knows that I appreciate and respect her knowledge and experience. I always ask for her advice regarding my pets’ well-being and do not hesitate to bring my pets to the hospital whenever I have concerns about their health, above and beyond checkups twice a year. She is also aware that I obtain information from a variety of other sources and that I become concerned and wary when there is a real discrepancy or controversy.

“Although she stresses the importance of following her recommendations, she has come to understand that I feel a strong sense of personal responsibility in the decisions made and their effect on the long-term well-being of my pets. If I have serious doubts about a stand that she takes, I will seek a second opinion, elsewhere. On this day, I guess you could say that we agreed to disagree.”

Antibody titer test results showing that no, Otto does NOT need to be vaccinated yet!

Diane is a little saddened that she and the veterinarian were unable to reach common ground, or at least have a more comfortable dialogue, noting, “It’s important for me to have a good rapport with the vets who care for my beloved pets. It’s important to me that they consider themselves an essential part of a team working for the well-being of the animals. Open communication and teamwork between pet owners and their veterinarians is essential.”

How antibody titer tests may affect your decisions
Antigens are any substance that the immune system identifies as an invader and responds to by producing a chemical defense: antibodies. When everything is working as it should, your dog’s immune system will recognize disease antigens that were introduced to his system via a vaccine (weakened or killed) or by natural exposure to the antigen that causes the disease (viral or bacterial).

A “titer” is a measurement of how much antibody to a certain antigen is circulating in the blood at that moment. The result is usually expressed in a ratio. A positive titer test result is strongly correlated with a good antibody response to either a recent infection or vaccination. A dog who has received “core” vaccines and who displays a positive antibody titer test result should be considered protected from the diseases for which he was vaccinated (meaning, he doesn’t need vaccines at that time).

Your dog must undergo a blood draw in order to have an antibody titer test. Labs such as Antech, IDEXX, and most veterinary college laboratories offer these tests. Antibody titer testing is typically run for parvovirus and distemper, since the dog’s antibody response to these two antigens is highly predictive as to the dog’s immunologic competence in dealing with any other antigen to which he has been exposed.

Rarely, there are exceptions. When an antibody titer test is negative, the owner and veterinarian should consider revaccinating and then testing the titers again. It may turn out that the animal simply needed another exposure to the antigen in order to stimulate a stronger immune response. Or, it may develop that the dog lacks the ability to respond normally to vaccines, that is, by mounting a proper immune response. In this case, the owner and veterinarian have gained very valuable information about the dog’s compromised immune status – information they never would have gained by simply vaccinating and assuming the dog was “protected,” as is usually the case with healthy dogs.

Dr. Kay comments, “There are several reasons I can think of why a vet might be loathe to run titers, but of these, I consider only a couple of them to be ‘honorable.’” Two examples she gives are:

  • Some veterinarians question the accuracy of titers in terms of accurately assessing immunity.
  • If a dog is truly at a high risk of infectious disease, revaccination might be a safer bet than relying on the results of an antibody titer test. She adds, “Very few dogs are truly in this situation, such as those who live in the midst of lots of completely unvaccinated dogs and in a lower socioeconomic setting.”

When I pressed Dr. Kay on the first point, asking what information “Dr. Doe” would have that trumps information provided by someone such as Dr. Schultz, she replied, “You will get no argument from me on this. I suppose that if Dr. Doe professes that titer tests are not accurate, one could ask to see the data that leads him (or her) to this conclusion.”

Although Dr. Wynn adds, “If a distemper or parvo titer is positive, we know that the dog is protected. If it is negative, the dog might be protected, but we have no practical further test to know whether or not it is. Hence, some veterinarians have said the titer isn’t accurate to point out that we don’t know what a negative titer means.” In the case of negative titers, Dr. Schultz recommends revaccination, even though the dog could already be protected.

If you choose to vaccinate
If you determine that your dog is in need of vaccination, consider the following:

  • Ask the veterinarian to perform the health exam and other tests first; you might even wait to vaccinate until those results are in, and schedule a follow-up vaccine visit once you know your dog is in the clear, health-wise.
  • Avoid a combination vaccine (five-in-one-type vaccinations) that offers multiple vaccines in only one shot. Note: some veterinary clinics only carry this type of vaccine. We recommend that you look elsewhere for care.
  • Do not vaccinate your adult dog more frequently than every three years (unless local conditions suggest a heightened need for Lepto, Bordetella, or Lyme vaccines; these each last a year or less).
  • At a minimum, try to schedule the rabies vaccine for a different visit than the other vaccines, if your dog needs them. The rabies vaccine should be administered by itself at a later date, apart from the other three “core” vaccines (distemper, parvo-virus, and adenovirus), and in another part of the dog’s body.

If you’re considering vaccinating simply for financial reasons (because vaccines cost less than running a titer test) a well-planned vaccine/titer strategy might have you coming out ahead in the long run if you scale back on vaccines and run titers on a strategically planned schedule.

Veterinary medicine today has advanced to the point of acknowledging that there is no single “perfect” vaccine program; vaccine programs must be tailored to the specific needs of each animal. Although there is a tendency to want to treat all dogs the same, the program should be designed for the individual, not the masses. The dog’s health, age, environment, activities, lifestyle, and whether he has previously had any adverse vaccine reactions all need to figure in to the equation.

If you encounter a veterinarian who continues to advocate yearly vaccination, schedule a sit-down talk with her, or take your business elsewhere. In Dr. Kay’s book, she notes that a “deal breaker” when choosing a veterinarian is when the clinician “vaccinates dogs for everything, every year.”

It’s up to you
Don’t expect your veterinarian to ask you broadly what you want to do when you take your dog in for an annual exam. Most veterinarians, unless prompted by the client, will assume that you’re there for “the usual” and will go ahead and recommend annual vaccinations. It is up to you to educate yourself and advocate for your dog and know what vaccines and tests might benefit him, and to know the laws concerning how frequently the rabies vaccine must be administered.

If you and your veterinarian are not on the same page, try having a rational, objective discussion. Put yourself in her position and try to understand her concerns. Take a step back to be sure that what you propose is reasonable. Keep in mind that taking your dog in regularly for annual checkups will help your veterinarian to develop further trust in you and your intentions. If you’ve got a good relationship and you’re armed with the facts, you just might be able to reach common ground.

Lisa Rodier is a frequent contributor to WDJ. She lives in Alpharetta, Georgia, with her husband and two Bouviers, and volunteers with the American Bouvier Rescue League.

Comments (14)

I don't do titres. I can't see the point. There is nothing that any vet can do to 'make' me have vaccinations or boosters for my dogs. Nor to make me take my healthy dog in for an annual check-up.

My dogs have their baby vaccinations -- and that is it. In the 'bad old days' that is all dogs were ever given and, unless the dog was kept in isolation for many years, comminity exposure keept teh immunity up.

I would have me dogs boosted IF they were to go into Boarding Kennels. Otherwise I see the vet when I am worried or the dog is injured.

I've had dogs die of cancer, dogs die of baiting, and dogs die of unavoidable genetic diseases. I've not lost any to disease.

Posted by: Jenny H | February 18, 2014 6:04 PM    Report this comment

I don't do titres. I can't see the point. There is nothing that any vet can do to 'make' me have vaccinations or boosters for my dogs. Nor to make me take my healthy dog in for an annual check-up.

My dogs have their baby vaccinations -- and that is it. In the 'bad old days' that is all dogs were ever given and, unless the dog was kept in isolation for many years, community exposure keeps the immunity up.

I would have m dogs boosted IF they were to go into Boarding Kennels, because you will be putting them in a situation that risks heavy exposure to pathogens. Otherwise I see the vet when I am worried or the dog is injured.

I've had dogs die of cancer, dogs die of baiting, and dogs die of unavoidable genetic diseases. I've not lost any to disease.

Posted by: Jenny H | February 18, 2014 6:03 PM    Report this comment

for those with an interest I have a VERY good document about titers on my "Titer Project" page. www.frontierrots.com/titerproject.htm Also for those skeptical about titers, you might find my page also of interest. In viewing the page you will see 1 dog, Annie, listed with a 2013 date but no results- she has not yet gone for her final titer (she's turning 8 and I don't do them beyond this age), her almost 15 year old sire died a few weeks ago and we will take her in for her titers once his final bill is paid off

Posted by: rottlady | September 3, 2013 10:55 PM    Report this comment

I've been trying for years to get my vet to do titers instead of vaccines. He refuses to do it because he says that even if the titers show that they have ample protection, there's no way of knowing when that protection will be depleted. I'm seriously considering changing vets (not just because of this but for several other reasons, most having to do with what I consider to be overly aggressive treatment and at times, bullying and harassing me to let him do unneeded, expensive tests -- also his office isn't up-to-date, something that nearly cost one of my dogs its life).

I'm so thankful for this article as I talk with other vets. This gives me more than my "gut feelings" to discuss with them. Thank you!

Posted by: JanU | December 28, 2012 11:00 PM    Report this comment

Australia...to the person who mentioned not having to worry about rabies....

Is there absolutley no rabies of any kind in Australia?

I believe they have had some in bats in the U.K.

The United States has been clear of canine strain since the 70's but we have it in raccoons, faxes, skunks, coyotes and mostly in bats.

Just curious is there is any strain at all there.

Posted by: kaylor | May 11, 2012 6:28 PM    Report this comment

I'm thankful that, living in Australia, I don't have to worry about the rabies vaccination - one of the advantages of living on an island! I'd feel much happier about booster vaccinations if they could be done individually, ie, parvo one week, distemper the next & so on. So far as I'm aware only the parvo shot is available on its own. I just think it's too much for their immune systems to have them all at once. Luckily I have an enlightened vet who is happy to titre test & so that's what we've done after my golden retriever had her 1 year booster to her puppy shots.

With regards to the KC vaccine - I've never given it to my girl since she isn't boarded. When she was a puppy I had another dog who did get KC - I was certain my girl would get it since she was only 6 months old & had never been vaccinated but she didn't get it. This was despite them having daily games of "bitey-face" before, during & after the KC in the other dog. I know she's also been directly exposed to it on at least one other occasion, again without getting it. I put it down to her good genes & her daily raw diet keeping her immune system in good stead!

Posted by: Muriel N | May 11, 2012 9:42 AM    Report this comment

Very good article. The laws on Rabies vaccines are the reason why I got involved in The Rabies Challenge Fund. They work to change state and county laws and add medical exemptions for dog's who will die if they receive vaccines. My dog's both have autoimmune diseases and one was caused by a rabies vaccine. We are a long way from everyone else catching on. That's why it's so important to have magazines like Whole Dog journal to spread more information most people don't know. Thanks WDJ

Posted by: LYNDSEY M | February 21, 2011 9:53 PM    Report this comment

This is on another subject. I just found out that My Vet will " price match". I have three Rottweilers - one that I just rescued - so I need to save whenever and wherever I can. I looked at 1800 Pet Meds on line for Interceptor (Heartworm prevention). When I called my Vet's office to request a prescription so that I could take advantage of the better pricing, I was told that they would match the price as long as I bring in a copy of the offer. Boy, I wish I had known that along time ago. I wanted to share this for others who might be able to also get a better price from the Vet. Rochelle

Posted by: Rochelle | August 30, 2010 2:35 PM    Report this comment

Great article! I have CathyD's same problem: convincing my boarding kennels to accept the 3 yr vaccines. Thanks for posting that, CathyD, I saw your post just as I'd finished writing the exact same thing here:) I do stretch the time between vaccines out because my dogs seem so lethargic after they have them done, but... I've got two reputable kennels here in my area, who will not board the dogs unless all shots are within 1 year old and I've got the papers for proof. I don't believe the kennel operators understand the concept of 'titers', therefore they don't accept them. So how DO we educate the kennels on this concept? Thanks for the info, and thanks to CathyD for posting this issue.

Posted by: CAROL R | August 11, 2010 9:02 AM    Report this comment

Hi Cathy,

Perhaps you could get a letter from your vet explaining the titers and how they prove your dogs have sufficient immunity to prevent infection. I think that will work for the DHPP vaccine. I don't think the kennel will accept titers for Bordetella since that is a bacterial infection (it can have a viral component in some infections) and the vaccine is not very long lasting at all (some boarding kennels require it every 6 months since it doesn't always even last a year). It also spreads through kennels, so they probably don't want to take any chances with it since they have to worry about their other boarders' health too. I think you can convince them about the DHPP vaccine but I'm not so certain about the Bordetella vaccine.

Posted by: vetgirl12 | July 29, 2010 8:24 PM    Report this comment

Hi Paula,

A titer is a good idea if you're concerned about over-vaccination, especially if she is still in poor health And if the titer ultimately shows she needs a booster you can give it to her then. Your other option is to just give her the booster if your vet feels her immune system can handle it. She may never have received her core puppy vaccines if she was in a puppy mill, so she may very well need the booster. I would definitely talk to your vet about your concerns and see what he/she would recommend.

Posted by: vetgirl12 | July 29, 2010 8:10 PM    Report this comment

After reading this article, I feel like I need to get far more information. I have recently adopted a 2+ year old pug who was rescued from a puppy mill and was in terrible condition. Good vet care has brought her back to increasingly better health but now my vet is recommending a distemper shot and booster before we proceed w/ spay, dental and eye surgery. Rescue vet records show that only one distemper shot was give in May 2010 and my vet says it does not assure coverage because a booster was not given. It appears that the titer test might be a good approach but I am fearful of not giving this girl everything she needs since her health has already been compromised in the mill. Any thoughts about this??? Thanks

Posted by: Paula C | July 28, 2010 10:54 AM    Report this comment

This is a great article. I have been having titers drawn for years on my dogs after one of them had a reaction to the Lepto vaccine two years in a row. (Which meant trips to the Vet ER and considerable expense.) The biggest hurdle that I encounter with doing titers is that Boarding Kennels will not accept a dog who has not been vaccinated yearly for the DHPP and Bordatella and they will not accept titers. This has created a major hassle for me and as a result I cannot board them. I don't want a pet sitter living in my home while I am on vacation. Any suggestions of how to educate the Boarding Kennels?

Posted by: CATHY D | July 27, 2010 1:04 PM    Report this comment

Great article--I agree with spacing vaccines and trying to do them every three years. But to be fair to vets, many of them carry the 1 year vaccines because some clients want the less expensive option of an annual vaccine (I know it's not cheaper in the long run). So be sure to ask for the 3 year vaccines when you do vaccinate. Also, I've talked with a really trusted veterinary mentor (I'm in vet school) about the whole titer issue, and she said that rabies tends to give longer immunity than the DHPP vaccine. However, it's harder for vets to "not" give the rabies vaccine since it's required by law. The DHPP vaccine decreases earlier, and is more critical when an animal is really young or really old (both times when the immune system is weaker and more susceptible to those diseases). So titers are especially important for DHPP if a client wants to vaccinate her pets only when necessary.

Posted by: vetgirl12 | July 25, 2010 12:04 AM    Report this comment

Add your comments ...

New to Whole Dog Journal? Register for Free!

Already Registered?
Log In