Novel protein foods get recommended constantly for itchy dogs, but they’re widely misunderstood, starting with which dogs actually need one. Companion animal nutritionist Dr. Mary Cope, PhD, clears it up.
Whole Dog Journal executive editor Kate O’Connor sat down with Dr. Cope to talk through what a novel protein diet is and when it makes sense.
What is a novel protein food?
A novel protein diet uses a protein source your dog has likely never eaten, Dr. Cope explains, such as duck, venison, rabbit, kangaroo, alligator, or certain fish. The goal is to reduce exposure to the proteins that might be triggering a reaction. And it’s usually the protein, not the grain, that’s the issue: owners often blame grains, but common allergens are proteins like chicken, lamb, and beef.
Who it actually helps
Here’s the nuance owners miss: true food allergies in dogs are relatively rare. Chronic itching, recurrent ear infections, and some GI signs are more often caused by environmental allergies, seasonal triggers, or fleas. For a dog that genuinely has a food sensitivity, a novel protein can reduce itching and improve skin, ear, and GI issues. For a dog without one, it isn’t inherently better, just a different protein.
The drawbacks
Novel protein diets tend to cost more and can be harder to find. And a protein is only novel if your dog hasn’t had it, so if you’ve fed, say, bison treats in the past, bison isn’t novel anymore. That’s why Dr. Cope says your dog’s dietary history matters so much.
Novel protein vs. hydrolyzed protein
A novel protein is a new, unchanged protein. A hydrolyzed diet takes a protein (often chicken) and uses enzymes to break it into fragments too small for the immune system to recognize. Dr. Cope’s analogy: the immune system reacts to the whole “house” of a protein, so hydrolyzing it into “shingles and two-by-fours” lets it slip past. It’s not lower quality (digestion does the same thing), but it costs more, and it’s often used for strict elimination trials or when multiple sensitivities are suspected.
Don’t start one without your vet
Because so many itchy dogs don’t actually have a food allergy, Dr. Cope says to work with your veterinarian before switching. The wrong diet, or just changing foods, can make a real diagnosis harder, and a vet can design a proper elimination trial and flag hidden triggers like flavored medications and treats.
How to choose a novel protein
Dr. Cope doesn’t have one favorite; the best choice depends on exposure, budget, availability, and format. Rabbit, venison, and duck are common. She also points to some unusual options with a sustainability angle, including antelope, lean kangaroo, and Asian carp pulled from the Mississippi as an invasive species. Above all, she says, pick a protein that’s truly novel for your individual dog, from a manufacturer with good quality control, and watch that your dog tolerates and likes it.
The takeaway
Novel protein diets are a real tool for the right dog, but not an automatic upgrade for every itchy one. Watch the full interview above, and work with your veterinarian before making the switch.



