A couple nights ago, I awoke in the middle of the night to that one sound that no dog owner can ignore: that lurching sound of an impending vomit. I leapt out of bed and saw my younger dog, Woody, standing near my bed, trembling. He looked exactly like a toddler who woke up feeling crummy and sought out his mom so he could barf in front of her. Well, that’s exactly what he did do; he and my older dog Otto always sleep in the living room.
“Oh, puppy,” I said. “What happened?” I grabbed my phone and smashed buttons on it, trying to find the flashlight option through bleary eyes. I scanned the room with the light but couldn’t see any actual puddles of vomit, so I got up and walked him outside, in case he had to throw up some more. He walked out onto the lawn and peed, went to the outside water bucket and drank a little water, and then came back inside. No more trembling. He settled back onto the couch and I went back to bed.

In the morning, with clearer eyes, I found the vomit. It was, of course, on one of the only two rugs in the house, an antique Persian carpet runner in my bedroom. In the weak beam of my phone flashlight, I couldn’t differentiate between the pattern in the rug and the small (now mostly dried) puddle. There was some slimy stuff that was most certainly just digestive juices, bits of nearly digested kibble, and . . . a blob of something. I used some paper towel to pick it up, examining the blob closely.
A mystery from the depths…of Woody
At first I thought it was a piece of bone or glass, but it was soft, with rounded edges. It was rubbery – if not actual rubber. I took it to the kitchen sink and rinsed it off. It was for sure a hunk of something rubbery and opaque. I could make out some molded edges.
If this happened two or more years ago, I wouldn’t have even blinked. Woody chewed up lots of things when he was a puppy and adolescent dog, and he vomited up everything that was indigestible, usually within a day or two. I had a few surprises – as when he vomited up a piece of something I hadn’t even known was missing – but mostly I was able to say, “Ah, that’s a piece of that old Kong toy,” or “Finally, that chunk of the flying disk he ruined.”
But this time? He hasn’t chewed up anything for ages and ages. I can’t even remember the last time he chewed up a toy or a forbidden item. And I don’t at all recall any toy that we have ever had that was this particular color, a sort of a slightly translucent, light root-beer-bottle brown.
Could this thing have been in there for months or years? Is that even possible? Perhaps, once upon a time, it was colorful and had sharp edges from being chewed up, and it has lost color and gained smooth edges from marinating in digestive juices for years?
This was the theory proposed by my husband, anyway. “What are you talking about, he never chews up anything anymore?” he asked me, incredulous. “He chews up his Squeak balls all the time!”
On the hunt for damaged toys

That is not exactly correct. Both of my dogs like to chew on their favorite toy, the Planet Dog Squeak Ball, like they are chewing bubblegum. The Squeak appears to be the perfect texture, or offers the perfect amount of resistance for their jaws. But I don’t think either dog is exactly bent on destroying the Squeak balls; they just chew the balls so much, that eventually, the balls crack and start to fall apart. And when they start to fall apart, then one of the dogs (usually Otto) will lay down with the ball and chew it up into bits. It’s a process that takes months, but that goes fast at the end.
To test my husband’s theory, I hunted around the property, looking for all the Squeak balls in various stages of repair. I did actually find one that had a missing chunk that was vaguely the same shape as the perplexing lump from Woody’s midnight misadventure. But, no: It wasn’t a credible match. The baffling item is about twice as thick as the “walls” of the Squeak.
So the mystery lives on. What is that thing? How long has it been in there? Where did it come from? Is there more in there? I might never know.
Dogs!!





Why don’t you call planet dog and ask them what’s inside the balls your dogs love to chew and show them your pic?
When I saw the picture my first thought ‘Oh that’s the rubber tip from a cane or crutches’
Kind of amber colored with a slight curve.
Nancy, you have to have a thick skin to expose yourself to all these experts and their opinions!
People are so judgemental when it isn’t their pet that is involved. Any pet owner has experienced something of an unknown origin coming ” out of their animal”. Yes, they are animals – not humans!
I enjoy your articles and keep watching for any info on living with an older deaf dog. I would like some ideas on how to communicate better.
Whenever a toy starts looking worn, out it goes! Dealing with a Lab puppy, 10 months old right now, and frankly it is not fun. Bad energy mismatch. I watch him like a hawk.
I run on the paranoid side and always patrol the house for anything on the floor or within reach to avoid any disasters. He is a typical puppy with shoes! Fortunately he loves his crate and always wants to be with us so supervision in the house is ok. Outside I always supervise. So far so good.
It looks like a piece off of a rubber sole on a boot or work boot. I have even seen them with that same color and shape. Best of luck!
Hi, It is possible that it was lodged inside for years. I’ve had members in my group where the dog has vomited up socks etc months later
When my collie puppy, Gillie, was about 6 months old I found her with what remained of a 12 inch, brittle plastic rain gauge, the kind that you stick in the ground. I tried to piece the remaining shards together to determine how much she had actually swallowed and it wasn’t looking very good. We had a second rain gauge still in one piece to compare and it seemed there were many, many pieces missing. I followed her around the yard for the next week and only was able to identify one small piece that manage to pass through the other end. I am convinced the rest of the plastic is still sitting in her stomach. Where else could it have gone? That was 2 years ago!
My older dog LOVES to chomp on those Squeak balls also. I periodically check them by squeezing the balls to see if they are starting to break- the rubber kind of starts to break down and you can see little cracks.
Just had DH look at it with me, and we saw the ‘warty’ top. It look like a ‘heel’ fallen of a boot or walking shoe
At a guess, I’d say something made of silicon rubber,, Something like brake pads or pedal pads, maybe dropped of a passing vehicle? Or some thid to stop virbationd that dell of something in your hose yard>>