Whole Dog Journal
RSS / XML

Home
Give a Gift
Subscribers Only
Get Web Access Now
Start a Subscription
Free E-Newsletter
Books
Purchase Back Articles
Sample Articles
In Future Issues
Search
Contact Us
Links
Surveys
Customer Service



First Name: Last Name:
Address: Address:
City: State/Zip:
Email:

Letters 03/04: Whales and Dogs

Readers inquire about a popular “positive” training technique that marine mammal trainers now refrain from using.

The interview in the December issue (“Reinforcing Our Beliefs”) was fascinating. This year’s subscription to WDJ was worth that one article alone. SeaWorld trainer Chuck Tompkins’ description of the whale’s reaction to negative punishment was hair-raising.

I had read elsewhere that negative punishment can produce the same neuro-endocrine physiological response as positive punishment, but this graphic description of the type of physical reaction that can occur really got my attention.

I think that many positive trainers believe negative punishment is relatively innocuous and use it freely. But I am convinced that we should strive to eliminate all forms of punishment from our training. Because of the society that we live…


Subscriber Login
Purchase Selection
Subscribe to Whole-Dog-Journal.com