Features
January 2001 Issue
Electronic-Collars - Opinions Often Vary
Do electronic collars shock or stimulate dogs? Are they cruel and unnecessary or valuable training tools? WDJ airs the debate.
Because we feel deeply that dog training should be pleasurable and effective, and because we have personally witnessed innumerable successful demonstrations of completely pain- and fear-free training, we have taken the position that training tools and methods that inflict pain are inferior (a strong word, we know) to those that do not.
To continue reading this entire article you must be a paid subscriber.
Subscribe to Whole Dog Journal
Get the next year of WHOLE DOG JOURNAL for just $20. And access all of our online content - 1,000 dog training, health and nutrition articles- free of charge.
That's a savings of $9 off the regular rate. Or subscribe for two years for $30 and save even more. It's like getting the second year free.
Already subscribe but haven't registered for all the benefits of the website? Click here.
Subscriber Log In
Forgot your password? Click Here.

